Job Offer Comparison Calculator: Net Pay After Work-Related Costs
Compare two job offers side by side: gross total compensation, an estimated after-tax figure, and what is left after work-related commuting, childcare and pet care costs.
Offer A (e.g. In-Office Role)
Offer B (e.g. Remote / Flexible Role)
Offer B Nets $1,320/Yr More After These Costs
| Compensation & Lifestyle Metric | Offer A (In-Office) | Offer B (Remote) | A minus B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gross Total Comp (Year 1) | $221,000 | $194,500 | +$26,500 |
| Annual Commute Costs (Gas + Tolls + Parking) | -$6,600 | -$0 | -$6,600 |
| Extra Childcare & Extended Hours | -$7,200 | -$0 | -$7,200 |
| Midday Dog Walker / Pet Daycare | -$4,200 | -$0 | -$4,200 |
| Workplace Food, Coffee & Office Attire | -$2,400 | -$0 | -$2,400 |
| Net After Tax and Costs | $138,720 | $140,040 | -$1,320 |
At the assumed 28% tax rate, Offer A's base salary would need to rise by about $1,667 (to $161,667, with its 10% bonus on top) for its net after these costs to match Offer B. Offer A's work-related costs total $20,400 a year against $0 for Offer B.
What this calculator does
This calculator compares two job offers on what is left after tax and after the costs that come with the job itself. For each offer you enter base salary, bonus percentage, annual equity and any sign-on bonus, plus the monthly costs the role adds: commuting (fuel, tolls, parking or transit), extra childcare, pet care, and food and work clothing. It adds up first-year gross compensation, applies an assumed tax rate, subtracts twelve months of those costs, and shows the difference line by line. It also works out how much one offer's base salary would have to change for the two to come out even.
It is for anyone weighing an in-office role against a remote or hybrid one, or two offers with different mixes of salary, bonus and equity. The costs are yours to estimate; the calculator does not supply local prices.
How the math works
First-year gross compensation is base salary, plus base times the bonus percentage, plus annual equity, plus the sign-on bonus. The calculator applies one flat 28% rate to that total as a stand-in for federal, state and payroll taxes together; it does not use tax brackets, and the section below shows how that assumption compares with 2026 federal figures. Work-related costs are entered monthly and multiplied by twelve. They are subtracted after tax because they are paid from take-home pay: IRS Publication 463 treats the cost of getting between home and your regular workplace, including parking there, as a personal commuting expense that is not deductible.
Net after costs is gross compensation times 0.72, minus the annual costs. The equalizing salary change divides the gap between the two offers by 0.72 and by one plus the bonus percentage, because a raise in base salary also raises a bonus that is set as a percentage of base. The in-office days selector is a description of the role; the costs you enter are what the calculation uses.
Worked example
These are the default inputs. Offer A is an in-office role: $160,000 base, 10% bonus, $30,000 of equity and a $15,000 sign-on bonus, $221,000 in the first year. Offer B is remote: $145,000 base, 10% bonus, $25,000 of equity and a $10,000 sign-on bonus, $194,500.
- After the assumed 28% tax: $159,120 for Offer A and $140,040 for Offer B.
- Offer A's work-related costs: $6,600 commuting, $7,200 extra childcare, $4,200 pet care and $2,400 food and attire, $20,400 a year. Offer B has none.
- Net after costs: $138,720 for Offer A and $140,040 for Offer B, so Offer B comes out $1,320 ahead despite $26,500 less in gross pay.
- To break even: Offer A's base would need to rise by about $1,667, to $161,667, because at 72% after tax and with the 10% bonus each $1 of base adds about $0.79 of net.
The result is close, which is typical: here $20,400 of costs almost exactly offsets a $26,500 difference in gross pay, and small changes to the cost estimates or the tax assumption move the answer from one offer to the other. The next two sections show the two biggest of those sensitivities.
How the flat 28% compares with 2026 federal figures
The table computes federal income tax for a single filer with the 2026 brackets and $16,100 standard deduction from IRS release IR-2025-103, plus the employee's Social Security tax of 6.2% up to the $184,500 wage base, Medicare tax of 1.45%, and the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax above $200,000, per IRS Publication 15. It treats all compensation, including equity and bonuses, as wages and leaves out state tax and pre-tax deductions such as 401(k) contributions.
| Gross pay | Federal income tax | Social Security and Medicare | Effective rate before state tax | Tax at the flat 28% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $120,000 | $17,570 | $9,180 | 22.3% | $33,600 |
| $194,500 (Offer B) | $35,414 | $14,259 | 25.5% | $54,460 |
| $221,000 (Offer A) | $42,024 | $14,833 | 25.7% | $61,880 |
| $317,750 | $74,347 | $17,106 | 28.8% | $88,970 |
Before state tax, a single filer's combined federal rate is below 28% up to roughly $300,000 of pay and above it beyond that. In a state with an income tax the true total is higher, and for married couples filing jointly it is usually lower. Because the same rate is applied to both offers, an error in the rate mostly scales the gap rather than reversing it; it matters most when the offers are close. Sign-on bonuses and equity are also often withheld at the 22% supplemental rate, which affects when tax is collected but not how much is owed for the year.
Pre-tax benefits that can shrink the in-office costs
Two employer benefits can pay part of the in-office costs with pre-tax money, which the calculator does not model. For 2026, IRS Publication 15-B allows up to $340 a month for qualified parking and up to $340 a month for transit passes and commuter vehicles to be excluded from wages, and raises the dependent care assistance limit to $7,500 a year ($3,750 if married filing separately), up from $5,000.
| Offer A, default inputs | Amount paid pre-tax | Tax saved at 28% |
|---|---|---|
| Parking through a qualified parking benefit ($340 of the $550 a month commute) | $4,080 a year | $1,142 |
| Extra childcare through a dependent care FSA ($600 a month) | $7,200 a year | $2,016 |
| Total | $11,280 a year | $3,158 |
With both benefits, Offer A's net after costs rises from $138,720 to about $141,878, and it comes out about $1,838 ahead of Offer B instead of $1,320 behind. Both depend on the employer offering the benefit. The dependent care saving also applies only if the total dependent care you pay for, not just the extra amount the in-office role causes, fits under the $7,500 limit; a family already using its full allowance for other childcare gains nothing more. To approximate the effect in the calculator, reduce the monthly cost inputs by the tax saved.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is a higher salary in-office job offer sometimes worth less than a lower remote offer?
Because the costs of going to the office are paid from after-tax income, while the salary difference is taxed. At a 28% rate, each $1,000 of extra gross pay adds $720 of take-home, but each $1,000 of commuting or childcare costs a full $1,000. In this calculator's default example, $20,400 of in-office costs outweighs a $26,500 gross advantage by $1,320.
How much of a raise would make two offers equal?
Divide the gap in net pay after costs by the share of each extra dollar of base you keep. With a 28% tax rate and a 10% bonus on base, $1 of base adds $1.10 of gross and about $0.79 of net, so a $1,320 gap needs a raise of about $1,667. The calculator shows this figure for whichever offer is behind.
Are commuting costs tax-deductible?
No. IRS Publication 463 says costs of travelling between home and your main or regular place of work, including parking there, are personal commuting expenses and are not deductible, however far the commute. An employer can, however, provide qualified parking or transit benefits of up to $340 a month each in 2026 that are excluded from your wages.
Should I compare total compensation before or after taxes?
When one offer carries costs the other does not, comparing after tax gives the more consistent answer, because those costs come out of take-home pay. Subtracting them from gross pay instead would understate their weight: $20,400 of costs against a gross difference of $26,500 looks like a $6,100 advantage for the in-office offer before tax, but a $1,320 disadvantage after it.
How should equity and sign-on bonuses be counted?
The calculator counts one year of equity at the value you enter and the full sign-on bonus in year one. Restricted stock is taxed as wages when it vests at whatever the shares are then worth, so its value can move in either direction, and a sign-on bonus usually does not repeat in year two. For a multi-year view, run the comparison again with the sign-on bonus set to zero.
Sources
Related Tools
Disclaimer: Educational and scenario-analysis only; not tax, legal, or investment advice; consult a licensed CPA or advisor. The 28% tax rate is an assumption, not a bracket calculation, and the cost figures in the examples are illustrations.
Built and verified by The Breakeven Math — last reviewed September 18, 2026.